I Play Rocky (2026) Movie Review

Rocky is one of the quintessentially American movies. It will always exist within the firmament of American cinema. Say what you will about it, I think it is memorable for good reason. There is a blue-collar, underdog fantasy in Rocky, a fantasy which is undercut at the very end, such that the fantasy becomes a dream. The film mythologizes the American dream within the contexts of an American cinema renaissance that had largely represented such a dream as dead. It’s all a bit corny, frankly, but the cornball nature of it is also part of its charm.

I agree with the consensus that says that Rocky is great. It is the type of film that makes people believe that anything one sets their mind to is possible, so long as they properly situate their priorities and are determined to reach their goals.

It makes sense, then, when spectators at the premiere of Rocky stand up and cheer at the end of I Play Rocky, the Sylvester Stallone biopic directed by Peter Farrelly, which traces the making of Rocky from Stallone’s early days of trying to become an actor. It also makes sense, on paper, to consider remediating the creation of Rocky as itself a triumph of self-determination and grit. The real-life story emulates the fiction on-screen. Sly wanted to make it on his terms, just like Rocky.

This all makes sense, of course, until you realize that making a film about a special film is destined to not itself be special. At one point during the dramatic retelling of the shooting of Rocky — a shoestring Hail Mary throw where the production would be doomed if it fell behind schedule by just one day — filmmaker John Avildsen, played as a glib director-for-hire by Jay Duplass, describes what causes a good movie to become a great one. There is an intangible, indescribable “thing” at the core of great cinema, and it is up to Stallone to find and capture that thing as quickly as possible, because the production can only afford to shoot 1-2 takes for each setup.

Storytelling-wise, this is a decent conceit. This sets the stage for Anthony Ippolito, who plays an eerily perfect mirror of Stallone, to give a great one-scene performance, which in turn is Stallone’s great one-scene performance, which elevates Rocky to a new height. It’s a simplistic notion. I think what makes Rocky great is not one improvised monologue but the entire interior world of a character being lyrically presented on-screen through the guise of a sports film. Nevertheless, it is a simplistic notion that could make for a triumphal moment that distills the “thing” that made Sly Stallone such a remarkable Hollywood figure when Rocky hit theaters.

The problem? This triumphant “thing” is great for Rocky. But I Play Rocky doesn’t have a “thing” that elevates it above being the most boilerplate of industry biopics. When characters in the film stand up and applaud Rocky jogging up the steps of the Philadelphia Museum of Art, the film is recognizing that Rocky is a masterpiece. But nobody making I Play Rocky should be expecting audiences to stand up and applaud the film that recreates the cheerable moment. The ceiling of a film like this is a viewer who fondly recalls the older, better movie that is being replicated.

For my money, such a movie is not one worth seeing. If you are interested in seeing I Play Rocky, then boy do I have a movie for you. It’s called Rocky, and it’s pretty dang good.

I recognize this is slightly disingenuous. There is good reason why someone who loves the film would also enjoy the love letter to that film. The problem with this is, beyond providing some bits of trivia and faithful recreations of iconic scenes, I Play Rocky does not produce much else. Many a scene involves Ippolito as Sly trying to convince Hollywood money men that the film is going to succeed, and that, yes, he will play Rocky. Some scenes work to present Stallone as a struggling but impassioned worker who went from sleeping on the street to turning down six-figure signing fees. It all becomes repetitive. And as much as Ippolito does a superb Stallone, it is difficult to extract anything other than impression out of his performance.

I Play Rocky is not particularly remarkable. It is a feel-good reminder that great movies — movies that have that “thing” — exist. They just exist somewhere else, outside of the bounds of this movie.

I Play Rocky: C-


As always, thanks for reading!

—Alex Brannan (Letterboxd)

Leave a Reply. We'd love to hear your thoughts!