Madden (2026) Movie Review

David O. Russell just released a movie that makes me question whether David O. Russell has made a good movie in his career. My memories of Three Kings, Flirting with Disaster, and I Heart Huckabees are fond. But maybe I was wrong. His recent track record has not been great. It doesn’t help any, I’m sure, that Amazon is behind this latest project, which mostly looks like a feature-length commercial cum SNL sketch. The flat framing and static blocking, occasional comedian bit players, and shadow-less lighting makes it look like there are cue cards right off-screen and a live studio audience ready to applaud after a mediocre scene-ending button.

The film is about John Madden, of course. The Oakland Raider head coach turned media franchise unto himself, Madden was a legend of the game of football. The film about him, however, is barely able to convince the audience that Madden was a living, breathing human. Nicolas Cage looks and sounds like himself under heavy makeup; it is difficult to squint and see Madden in the performance. But it isn’t entirely Cage’s fault. The script lacks cohesive structure, instead transitioning from scene to scene using random pivots, often hinging on inadequate attempts at humor. In one instant, the Raiders win the Super Bowl. Two minutes later, a New England Patriot is in the hospital and Madden realizes he needs to be a family man. Next thing you know, a player is waving a gun around the locker room for who-knows-why reason. Madden and Raiders owner Al Davis (Christian Bale) pause the movie for two minutes to discuss their favorite cracker brand. In the third act, it becomes a subplot that Madden is afraid of flying.

None of it is particularly funny, and certainly none of it makes for a meaningful narrative retelling of Madden’s career. Take a moment to recall what you know about John Madden: coach, commentator, the name of the biggest sports video game franchise, Hall of Famer. This movie gives you all of these beats, and everything else is Russell’s screwball influence without the screwy and only a little ball (the film thankfully drops the awkward Xs and Os floating in Madden’s brain after act one).

The film is obsessed with how strange Madden is — Cage’s Madden tends to ramble endlessly with only semi-coherent sentences, sometimes to his dog. When I was a kid, I’d occasionally see Frank Caliendo do his most well-known impression (Madden) on the sketch show MADtv. Russell and co-writer Cambron Clark’s understanding of Madden seems to be similarly delirious and rambling. Only, Caliendo had decent comic delivery. And MADtv, not a perfect sketch show by any means, was at least invested in constructing structurally sound comedy. God bless Nic Cage, but this is far from his best role. When the film pauses for a montage of funny Madden bits, Cage is essentially performing Caliendo’s acting reel.

Madden is a film that mistakes speed for entertainment, stuff for substance. Crammed full of stuff (just stuff), one leaves the film learning nothing new about the man and caring little about any of the trivial stuff that stands in where character depth should be. The most exciting aspect of watching Madden is being perplexed, scene after scene, by the fact that the film continues to slide into a self-parody. You may start to feel that you are witnessing an elaborate prank. A star-studded prank populated by the likes of Christian Bale, Sienna Miller, Kathryn Hahn, and Nic Cage, but a prank nonetheless. For all I know, this is a prank. A prank on the viewer. A prank on Amazon. A prank on the legacy of John Madden. The film only makes textual sense to me if it turns out that Russell holds contempt for all three. Because otherwise, what is the point of Madden? To sell more video games?

Madden: D


As always, thanks for reading!

—Alex Brannan (Letterboxd)

Leave a Reply. We'd love to hear your thoughts!